Am I Famous Now…

...Creator And Destroyer

Controversy and Quick Fire Blogging, Commenting. Censoring and Editing.

July 19th, 2007 by Franky · // Permalink

I’m the first one to admit I make errors and sometimes fire to quickly. Lately it has happened more than once, that I blogged and fired, only to censor myself few hours later. But most of times damage had already been done, your target already read your salvo. Only thing you can do is own up to it.

- Incoherent ramble. Stop. Move forward to related topic. -

There was some controversy over at Wisdump last weekend. Editorial, censorship and owner intervention, apology. The result is a highly damaged blog and image.
Where the owner and I thought it was a good move to disclose, admit the error and own up to it in a public apology, soon we were called down to earth.
Disclosure is important in the world of problogging, most of time highly appreciated even. But more had happened: the owner’s apology was edited by former editor.

After some days of ‘train wreck watching’, I took over the editorship of Wisdump and decided to edit the public apology back to it’s original state (read: without the edit of the former editor) and closed and deleted all comments for that entry.

I am aware that people might take this as a new case of censorship, but I will stand up and defend this decision, my decision. I think SplashPress took the right decision and there was no need for a collection of unsubscribe comments. I wonder how people would have reacted if the apology were Scriv’s.

Now, I’m looking forward to the challenge Wisdump and am sure we’ll soon be able to introduce some new authors and create a kicking team.
And with this, I close the ‘ping-o-matic train wreck’ mentally.

Tags: // 1,136 views

3 have made me smarter ↓

  1. Gravatar

    1 Matt Craven // Jul 20, 2007 at 1:04 am// View all comments by Matt Craven //

    I understand removing David’s comments… but removing the comments?

    That was just dumb. The damage had already been done - leave it up and move on.

  2. Gravatar

    2 franky // Jul 20, 2007 at 1:12 am// View all comments by franky //

    Thanks for your advice on that, Matt. I highly value that and will take it with me, even if I hope I won’t need it.

  3. Gravatar

    3 David Krug // Jul 22, 2007 at 2:29 am// View all comments by David Krug //

    Censorship is just that censorship call it what you will.

Comment Policy

Spam comments are not supported and will be deleted.

This site supports a dofollow policy for comments, accordingly I do reserve the right to remove your URL if your comment seems to be nothing more than a plug to your site. This is a non-disputable decision from my side.

Stay polite and ad rem in the comments. We all, me too, have had our child days, but have grown up. Flame comments will be deleted.
If you really want to flame, feel free and do it on your own blog. Feel free to link back.

Off topic comments will be deleted.